directed by Alan Parker

As a cinephile and a bookworm, I love how those two industries complement each other. We all know this popular question “what do you prefer – the book or the film?”, and I personally think we should appreciate both, because each enriches us with a different kind of experience. In fact, I believe watching a film and reading a book based on one story is super exciting, because we may compare them and get surprised by certain differences. Today’s recommendation is based on the book of the same name written by Frank McCourt. I haven’t read that book, but I’m surely adding it to my to-read list after seeing the film. If you haven’t heard of the story, I’m sure you’ll be both amazed and terrified by what this productions has to offer. It’s about a big family of six living in the US in the 1930s. Another member has just been born, little Margaret, but she dies shortly after. The tragedy is incredibly difficult for them all to deal with, that is why the mother, Angela (Emily Watson), is suffering from depression, and the father, Malachy (Robert Carlyle), starts drinking way too much. Since the parents cannot provide for their children, they get back to Ireland, where they both originally come from. The decision was quite strange because the situation in Ireland was much more complicated than in the US back then, yet the family moved. They all have to adapt to horrible conditions and live with a constant fear of death, which continuously takes them away one by one… It’s a very uncomfortable story told by the eldest son, Frank, who shares his whole childhood with us. Or actually lack of it. You don’t have to be good in history to know that the 1930s were a true nightmare in Europe, so watching this film you may feel speechless, as well as horribly grateful. Speechless what a human can go through, and grateful that you’re in a better situation right now. I hope you are, because I wouldn’t wish anyone to have a memoir like this one. The film is certainly culturally significant, because it presents authentic life of people back then and is better than most history classes I attended at school, that’s for sure. What I also appreciate this story for is numerous questions about faith. The family is very religious, yet they literally go through hell every single day. At one point, the mother says to her children that if they need anything, they should pray to Jesus, and one boy starts wondering if they could tell him they’re hungry. It’s a short moment in the film, yet it hit me hard. The topic of questioning God is very much present there, but I don’t want to share my personal opinions on that. Besides, even though this story is set in the 1930s, there are many moments covering the topic of feminism and toxic masculinity, which are more common in modern cinema. We see Angela who has to take care of all the children on her own, but we also see Malachy, who cannot provide for them and it is slowly killing him, because he doesn’t feel like a “real man”. And then, a bunch of little humans, who didn’t ask to be born into that world. If you’re looking for a difficult production, you’ve just found it. But it’s very good and you should definitely see it. I’m a fan of Emily Watson and Robert Carlyle, so seeing them together on the screen is incredibly satisfying.
My rating: 7/10
S.








